Fix or Upgrade? Appliance Choices That Matter

NEW YORK — We've all felt that sinking moment when a familiar hum goes silent: the fridge stops cooling, the washer won't spin or the oven won't heat on a busy weeknight. When an appliance quits, the big question follows fast: Do you repair it or replace it?

The right answer depends on age, repair cost, performance and whether a fix buys you meaningful extra life. With a little strategy, you can avoid overspending and keep your home running smoothly.

For most homeowners, the easiest starting point is the 50% rule: If the repair will cost less than half the price of a comparable new appliance, repair it. If it's more than half, replacement makes better long-term sense. But like most household decisions, the rule works best when you understand the context.

Start with current pricing. If you haven't shopped for appliances in years, sticker shock is real. Common household units run anywhere from a few hundred dollars to several thousand. A major repair on a midlife appliance may get you another few years of service and buy time to plan for a new model that fits your long-term budget.

Warranties and recalls tilt decisions heavily toward repair. If your item is still under warranty, the fix is often free or low-cost. Always check Recalls.gov or the Consumer Product Safety Commission before authorizing any work.

And then there's age. Most major appliances last 10 to 15 years, with outliers such as freezers and water softeners pushing well beyond. If your machine is bumping up against its expected lifespan, repair begins to look like a short-term patch rather than a long-term solution.

Finally, consider energy efficiency. Even modest improvements in refrigerator or washer design can trim utility bills. If your older model has been gulping power, upgrading may pay off faster than you think.

When to repair

Plenty of situations favor repair, especially for units that have been performing well up to the moment of breakdown. A newer appliance with a single failed component, for example, may still have years of usable life once it's fixed.

If performance has been strong, a sudden failure is often mechanical rather than systemic, and a qualified technician can restore it quickly. Repair also makes sense for homeowners with eco-friendly priorities. Extending the life of an efficient appliance keeps it out of the landfill, reduces manufacturing demand and often uses far fewer resources than building a new replacement.

And sometimes, you simply don't need new features. Many appliances evolve slowly; the dishwasher you bought a decade ago might still meet your needs just fine. A repair can maintain reliable performance without forcing a costly upgrade.

While DIY repairs can save money, be honest about your limits. Swapping an accessible part or cleaning a clogged filter is one thing; handling wiring, gas connections or internal plumbing is another. When the job involves safety risks or could void the warranty, call a pro.

When to replace

On the flip side, certain signs point clearly toward replacement. If your unit is approaching the decade mark and repair calls are becoming a yearly ritual, the math usually favors buying new. Hidden symptoms matter, too: A washing machine that no longer cleans well or a refrigerator that constantly cycles may be failing in ways unrelated to the immediate repair.

Poor energy performance is a big motivator. New models often carry dramatically improved efficiency ratings, especially in fridges, washers and dishwashers. What looks like a pricey replacement can quickly turn into a monthly savings plan on your utility bill.

And don't ignore modern features. If you've been eyeing smart controls, quiet-operation dishwashers, induction cooktops or advanced water-saving washers, a major breakdown is often the natural moment to upgrade.

Before finalizing a purchase, factor in installation costs, which can bump your total by $100 to $200 or more. Many manufacturers require professional installation to keep warranties valid. Still, if you've got the muscle and a truck, hauling the appliance yourself can shave off delivery fees.

© 2026 Ask Angi. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC; and Copyright © 2026 Paxton Media Group. All rights reserved.