State Appeals in Wetlands Permitting Squabble

TALLAHASSEE, Fla. – Florida has quickly launched an appeal after a U.S. district judge rejected a 2020 decision by the federal government to shift permitting authority to the state for projects that affect wetlands.

Attorneys for the state filed a notice Monday that is a first step in challenging the decision by U.S. District Judge Randolph Moss at the U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia.

The notice also said the state will seek a stay of Moss' decision while the appeal plays out. As is common, the notice did not detail arguments the state's attorneys will make in the appeal. The Washington, D.C.-based Moss on Friday issued a final judgment on almost all issues in the case. That came after a February ruling in which Moss vacated the transfer of permitting authority because he said federal officials had not followed required steps before making the 2020 decision.

The case has been closely watched by business and environmental groups, with the state saying in a court filing that Moss' February ruling could affect "pending permit applications for roads and bridges, hospital construction projects, school buildings and facilities, affordable housing, military base projects, power grid reliability projects (including construction of new power generation facilities and transmission lines), and various projects necessary to improve water quality in the Everglades, just to name a handful of examples."

The state sought a partial stay of Moss' Feb. 15 ruling, but the judge wrote Friday that a stay would be "neither workable nor desirable." He also wrote that the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers is prepared to review permits, as had been the case before the authority was transferred to the state.

Moss anticipated the appeal, saying the final judgment would help clear the way for the dispute to move forward.

"Although the court's (Moss') decision is unlikely to result in the dire consequences that Florida proffers - as noted the Corps stands ready, willing, and able to issue permits in Florida, as it did for decades before the EPA approved Florida's assumption application and as it does in 47 other states - Florida nonetheless has a legitimate and substantial interest in obtaining prompt appellate review of a decision and order that set aside a program to which it has devoted extensive time and effort," Moss wrote. "Florida may or may not prevail on appeal, but there is no just reason to delay its ability to seek review."

The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency approved the transfer of the permitting authority to the state in December 2020, about a month before former President Donald Trump's administration ended.

© Copyright © 2024 Palatka Daily News, Community Newspapers, Inc. All rights reserved.